Who should the next Boston Red Sox Manager be? I like Nomar Garciaparra among others

10 Oct

So who should be the Boston Red Sox manager to replace the fired Bobby Valentine?  If you don’t like the Red Sox or don’t care you might not think about it, but as a Red Sox and baseball fan it does give me some curiosity and I’m sure it does you too.

I have read that the Red Sox would like to pursue Toronto Blue Jays manager John Farrell who used to be a Red Sox pitching coach and still has a year on his contract. I have also heard about interest in Los Angeles Angels manager Mike Scioscia if he he is let out of his contract or let go by the Angels. Hard to figure he has managed there since 2000, and he led the Angels to the 2002 World Series title.

I as a fan who has no knowledge or other information, has my own ideas and they involve some former Red Sox and major league players, besides the gem in the rough of the coaching ranks that only baseball insiders know.

I like former Red Sox shortstop Nomar Garciaparra now an ESPN analyst. He is a young, bright and calm baseball mind. He is beloved in Boston as a player where he played from 1994 through the middle of the 2004 season when he was traded ironically before the Red Sox won their first World Series that season in 86 years. I think he would have a great demeanor for Boston Baseball where they need a great manager who can put up with egos, talent and the pressure of the Boston baseball market where they talk Red Sox baseball all year.

I thought of former Red Sox pitcher Curt Schilling also an ESPN Analyst, but he is quite outspoken and likes to talk on talk radio. He might be a wilder choice than Bobby Valentine was, but he does know baseball and pitching well and is also a hero from his bloody sock performance in Game 6 of the 2004 ALCS when he was hurt and won a big game against the Yankees in the legendary ALCS where the Red Sox came from 3-0 down to win. But being a former player alone doesn’t lead to greatness as a coach or manager of course. There are lots of great players who have failed and are not great coaches or managers

Other former players I thought of are Ryne Sandberg who has managed in the Cubs minor league system, Tony Gwynn who has over 3000 hits and is an excellent baseball strategist and coach. Also former Red Sox and Yankees third baseman Wade Boggs who also has over 3000 hits. These are just a few ideas among many others. I like Nomar Garciaparra the best as a choice for Red Sox manager, but you can argue he doesn’t have coaching experience. But a good baseball mind is what is needed and the demeanor to fit with the players and city. I think Nomar has this, but so do many others and a decision probably wont be made until after the playoffs. But we’ll see what happens and it is interesting discussion especially because its Boston Red Sox Baseball.  Best wishes and talk soon. Bratman


2 Responses to “Who should the next Boston Red Sox Manager be? I like Nomar Garciaparra among others”

  1. Elichap October 10, 2012 at 12:08 pm #

    Well, Sandberg has been hired by the Phillies … third base coach and defense tactician. So, he’s off your list. I do like the idea of former players managing. Even tho’ the White Sox didn’t make it into the play-offs, Robin Ventura managed quite well for his rookie season. Manager Matheny has done extremely well with the Cardinals. Did they inherit good teams ~ yes. But a lot of managers do … rookie or otherwise. However, I feel their personalities & demeanor had a lot to do with their successes. Rookies .. yes. Even tho’, each has earned the respect of their team members. The Red Sox need a calm, positive force in a manager to help re-vamp their program. The RS have good players … they need a guide to help them realize their full potential. Great thoughts, great blog .. but who knows ~ Sandberg may just be back w/the RS in the future. Have a great day!! Always, Eli-B

  2. berniebrew October 10, 2012 at 1:29 pm #

    I like Nomar Garciaparra’s demeanor, personality and he is a good baseball man and beloved in Boston. I think he would be a good man for Boston Baseball. But he hasn’t managed them of course so we’ll see who gets the job. I’nm just the voice of the fan and management won’t really listen to us nor should they. It’s a business. But we can give an opinion and this is mine. Nomar Garciaparra for manager of the Boston Red Sox. They can always fire him later lol.
    Thanks as always for the great comment Beth and have a great day! Bratman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: